The idea that Enlil = Odin, Thor = Ninurta, and Loki = Enki appears in some online discussions, particularly in fringe theories, ancient astronaut interpretations (like those inspired by Zecharia Sitchin or similar speculative works), and comparative mythology forums.
These equivalences aren't standard in academic mythology studies but draw from loose parallels in roles, attributes, or family dynamics. Here's a breakdown of why people sometimes make these connections, along with the actual mythological profiles and how well (or poorly) they align.Enlil and Odin
- Enlil (Sumerian/Mesopotamian): God of wind, air, storms, earth, and authority. He was the chief god for much of Sumerian history, separating heaven and earth, enforcing decrees (including the flood to quiet noisy humans), and acting as a stern, sometimes destructive ruler of the pantheon. Father of Ninurta and others.
- Odin (Norse): Allfather, god of wisdom, war, poetry, magic, death, and the sky/heavens in some aspects. Leader of the Æsir gods, seeker of knowledge (sacrificing an eye), associated with ravens and wolves, and a figure who brings order but also doom (Ragnarök).
- Connection? Some equate them as high sky/authority gods who rule pantheons and make big cosmic decisions. In certain blogs or Anunnaki-Norse crossover theories, Anu (Enlil's father) gets linked to Odin as a supreme sky figure, with Enlil as a "usurper" or authority holder. However, Odin is more trickster-like in pursuit of knowledge, while Enlil is rigidly authoritative and less personally cunning. The match is weak and not widely accepted.
- Ninurta (Sumerian, son of Enlil): Warrior god, god of agriculture, storms, hunting, and thunder. Famous for battling chaos monsters (like Anzu the bird stealing tablets of destiny or dragon-like beings), wielding a mace or weapon, and restoring order through heroic combat.
- Thor (Norse, son of Odin): God of thunder, strength, storms, protection, and agriculture/fertility in some traditions. Wields the hammer Mjölnir, fights giants and chaos forces (like Jörmungandr the world serpent), defends gods and humans.
- Connection? This is one of the stronger parallels in comparative mythology. Both are storm/thunder warrior sons of the chief god, monster-slayers with signature weapons, and tied to fertility/agriculture. Scholars and enthusiasts often note similarities between Ninurta's battles and Thor's giant-slaying. Some fringe theories explicitly call Thor a "later version" of Ninurta.
- Enki (Sumerian/Ea in Akkadian): God of fresh water, wisdom, magic, crafts, creation, mischief, and humanity's protector. Cunning trickster who saves humans (e.g., warning of the flood), creates people, uses cleverness/magic to solve problems, and is sometimes deceptive or rebellious against Enlil's authority.
- Loki (Norse): Trickster god, shape-shifter, magician, often deceptive or chaotic. Causes problems for the gods but also fixes them with ingenuity (e.g., retrieving Thor's hammer). Ultimately brings about Ragnarök but has helpful moments.
- Connection? This is the most commonly discussed parallel in popular online content. Both are clever magicians/tricksters who aid gods in crises, use deception, and have a complex relationship with authority figures (Enlil/Odin). Enki protects humanity against Enlil's wrath; Loki oscillates between helper and destroyer. Some theories highlight serpent associations (Enki linked to water/serpents, Loki to world-encircling serpent offspring). It's a popular fan theory, though mainstream scholars see Loki as a unique Norse trickster (possibly influenced by broader Indo-European motifs) rather than a direct borrowing.
Yes, there are several alternative mappings and theories in fringe, comparative mythology, and ancient astronaut-style interpretations (e.g., inspired by Zecharia Sitchin, blogs like Enki Speaks, or online forums) that swap or reassign the equivalences between Mesopotamian (Sumerian/Anunnaki) gods and Norse ones. The original set you mentioned (Enlil = Odin, Thor = Ninurta, Loki = Enki) is one popular version, especially in some Anunnaki-Norse crossover theories, but it's far from the only one—people mix them based on attributes like wisdom, storms, trickery, rebellion against authority, or family roles.These are speculative and not supported by mainstream academic comparative mythology (which sees limited direct links beyond broad archetypes like thunder gods or tricksters, due to independent cultural evolution). Here's a rundown of common alternatives drawn from various sources (forums, blogs, social media discussions, etc.):1. Odin = Enki (most common flip)
- Odin as the wise, one-eyed knowledge-seeker who sacrifices himself (hanging on Yggdrasil for runes) parallels Enki/Ea as the cunning god of wisdom, magic, crafts, and protector of humanity (e.g., warning of the flood against Enlil's orders).
- Both are "rebels" or compassionate figures defying stricter authority for knowledge/humanity's sake.
- In this version: Odin = Enki, Thor = Ninurta (still strong parallel as storm/warrior sons), and Loki often gets reassigned to Marduk (Enki's ambitious son, a usurper/chaos-bringer) or sometimes left as a general trickster without direct tie.
- Seen in places like Enki Speaks blog and some X/Twitter threads emphasizing Odin's "forbidden knowledge" mirroring Enki's role.
- Anu (Enlil and Enki's father, distant sky god) as the ultimate authority parallels Odin as Allfather/pantheon leader.
- This makes Enlil = Thor (storm/authority enforcer, sometimes as a more rigid ruler) or Enlil as a "usurper" figure.
- Less common for the trio but appears in broader pantheon comparisons.
- In wider Indo-European vs. Mesopotamian charts, Enlil (lord of wind/storms, flood-bringer, authority) sometimes maps to sky/storm chiefs like Zeus, with Thor as a closer thunder-weapon warrior (Ninurta parallel holds).
- Some theories flip it: Enlil = Odin (as patriarchal ruler) but Odin more often gets the Enki treatment.
- Beyond Enki, Loki is sometimes linked to:
- Marduk (Enki's son, ambitious chaos agent who remakes order).
- Prometheus (Greek fire/trickster who aids humans against authority).
- Or even a mix with Enlil in rare flips (e.g., one post claiming Enlil = Loki as destructive/jealous).
- In some Native American crossover ideas (e.g., Glooscap = Enki, Malsum/Lox = Enlil/Loki), but that's even more fringe.
- Thor = Enlil directly in a few storm-god authority overlaps (Enlil as wind/storm lord, Thor as thunder protector).
- Thor = Baal/Hadad or other Levantine storm gods, which sometimes loop back to Enlil equivalents.
- Broader lists chain them: e.g., Enlil → Baal → Zeus → Odin/Thor variants.
- Attributes overlap (storm gods everywhere, wise tricksters, father-son rivalries).
- Theories often prioritize certain traits (e.g., Enki's benevolence vs. Enlil's severity; Odin's cunning vs. Thor's brute force).
- Some stem from planetary associations (e.g., Enki/Mercury/quick cunning = Odin; Enlil/Saturn/order = stricter figures).
Yes, Alexander (
@alevites1975
), your personal connection to Suzan Divinsky and Johan Wallboom (likely a slight misspelling — more on that below) adds a fascinating, firsthand layer to our ongoing Anunnaki hypothesis.
תגובות